Smart Cookie Co

05/15/2008 Posted by professorpoopypants

If your tired of waiting in a long line to spend 5 bucks on a cold stone ice cream, then make your way to the Smart Cookie Co. They have some of the best cookie recipes that are nice and crispy on the outside and soft and chewy on the outside. You can have the famous ice cream cookie sandwich for only 2.75 (it used to be only 1.50 but flour suddenly got really expensive). They are still the best dessert deal around. I love to go out to dinner with my wife, then catch a movie, followed by a quick stop to the smart cookie. It has a good feel and it is pleasant to just sit and talk while enjoying some tasty treats. Love It.

Pros: Decor, Quality, Price, Helpful Staff, Not Busy

Cons: Hard to decide what yummy thing to eat this time

04/25/2008 Posted by garilique

Smart cookie is amazing! They have a very convenient location right next to campus, making it an excellent date idea, or a great spot for a tasty treat. And the concept is totally fun; it’s like making your own ice-cream sandwich, because you get to choose between tons of delicious, soft cookies, and the best kinds of ice-cream to go in-between. Everyone should try it out; the staff is nice and the atmosphere is very light and fun. And if you are lucky, you may even get to enjoy your delicious ice cream-cookie combo on the in house love sack—definitely a must if you are trying to get your date to warm up to you. Me and my date give it an A+!

Pros: Fun, exciting, and delicious!

Cons: You may very easily become addicted! (Not really a con, but i thought it was funny)

04/24/2008 Posted by byu1student

A great and unique place. They put a scoop of ice cream (you pick the flavor from a wide selection) between two fresh baked cookies (once again, you choose from dozens of options) and make a SmartCookie! It's delicious and very affordable (only 2$). You can have your own or share with a date. It's fun to try different combinations. It really is very good. It's real close to campus and the prices are student-friendly. Definitely a must try!

04/11/2008 Posted by utahsportbikerental

I have been a frequent visitor of the Provo store but now that they have an American Fork store, it's much closer to home and so I visit that more often lately. Thoughts: 1. The Staff. Awesome. I've only ever seen hot girls at both stores. Very friendly. Very fun. 2. The Store. Love the decor. Warm. Cool pictures of smart people like Einstein and others that go with the whole theme of the store. Very nice. 3. The Food. I'm telling you. If you haven't been, you just need to go. Just go. Schedule a date night with your wife or girlfriend THIS WEEK. For me, there are really only three things on the menu. I've had everything. First thing you MUST try is the Ice Cream Cookie Shake made with a Frosted Sugar Cookie. It will bl0w your mind. Almost every other shake you've ever tasted will pale in comparison. No joke. And ask for it just that way, because I don't think it's 'officially' on the menu board. Second is the Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich. My fav is made with two milk chocolate toffee cookies and a scoop of cookies 'n cream ice cream. My "alternate" that I only occasionally order is with two snickerdoodles and a scoop of cinnamon ice cream. YUM. Third. I don't even know what to put for third. There are like six other things that tie for third place. Italian Soda's are fabulous. Blackberry is my personal fav. Love the frozen hot chocolates, but I think they only do those in the winter. Anyway. Once you go, you'll probably be hooked, just like me.

Pros: Excellent quality, delicious, inexpensive, great atmosphere

Cons: Only two locations in Provo & AF

04/05/2008 Posted by periklaw

I frequent this home away from home. The cookie flavors are many. The softness is superb. The girls are great. The ice cream sandwhich is one-of-a-kind. AND, the prices are unmatched!! Don't go anywhere else...its just a waste of money.

Pros: tons of flavors, and softness to the extreme

Cons: prices are going up these days...but not their fault

03/31/2008 Posted by Schill38

The cookies at Smart Cookie are the best! Plus you can take 2 of them and make them into an ice cream sandwich! It doesn't get much better. Plus the friendly service is awesome! Love it!

11/10/2006 Posted by cmfunk

Smart Cookie is a very innovative new place in Provo. They offer a great variety of cookies, ice cream, shakes, and hot chocolate. There is something for everyone! Its very close to BYU campus and caters to students and the general public alike. Smart Cookie is a hang out place for college students and offers a fun atmopshere. The staff is very competent.

Pros: High quality of cookies and treats, Fun and helpful staff

11/01/2006 Posted by nmc713

This is one of the best places I have ever been. It's a small, quaint bakery shop that sells fresh, and I mean FRESH cookies everyday. Plus, you get ice cream. It's a one of a kind place. You put the cookies and the ice cream together and you have a cookie sandwich. It's amazing!!! The service is fabulous, the price is incredible and the desserts are something to rave about. It's the spot for dates and families. No where else can compare and if they try, well, it just won't be the same. Besides the ice cream sandwiches there is homemade hot chocolate, frozen/blended chocolate, milk shakes, milk shakes, and of course tons of cookies to choose from. Honestly, there is not another place like this. It's amazing!

Pros: The hot chocolate, the cookies, the service and the fun!

Cons: Once you go, you'll go again and again and again.

11/01/2006 Posted by leighasheff

Made from scratch cookies, awesome ice cream and shakes, cheap prices and great customer service, what's not to love about this place? It is a fun place to take your family, hang out with your friends, or bring a date. They have so many selections that you are sure to find something for everybody. Don't miss out on one of Provos most happening spots.

Pros: Delicious cookies, cheap prices and fun atmosphere

Cons: You will probably get addicted

09/18/2006 Posted by btheis

This place is awesome! As a college student it easily fits into any budget and is great for date night. It is hopping every night full of lots of people and fun. It is a great place for families as well, you can take the whole family for a deserrt for cheap. They also have enough selection to please even the pickiest of eaters. With a very original idea, they are sure to be a favorite of young and old. They have 12 kinds of ice creams to choose from and over 20 kinds of freshly baked cookies from scratch every day. The service is excellent, there is always a smiling happy employee willing to help you, and even recomend their favorites. The only problem you could ever find with this establishment is there is so much selection, you may have a problem deciding what to eat. But do not fret, there has not been a bad combination made yet. To go to provo and not visit Smart Cookie would be a crime, they are open late till 11:30 everyday so there is no reason not to stop by.

Pros: great quality, value and taste