Over The Counter Cafe

Wonderful neighborhood diner. We sat at the counter of this wonderful, homey, neighborhood diner and enjoyed a hot breakfast while watching the cook, who was less than a foot from us and working in a space in which he could barely turn around. I mean, you can't find an atmosphere like that just anywhere!

Excellent food and customer service are offered by this little gem of a diner in East Millcreek. Highly recommended.…

My favorite spot :). Super yummy breakfast and lunch! I always come in, staff is always friendly and remember you. Its a place where everyone knows your name :) Nothing bad i could ever say about it! I love getting a burger any way you want it, or those eggs and bacon mmmmmm. Everything is great and just found out everything is local, even better!…

Best Breakfast, hands down. This is my favorite place to eat. I can walk in and get a yummy breakfast and good cup of coffee, and be myself. The food is great - real eggs, cheese, potatoes, bread - always fresh! The kitchen is right in the middle so you can see them cooking your breakfast. The people are friendly and down to earth. Their prices are good too. I'm a customer for life!…

Unsanitary. Just plain dirty.. I am really surprised this place has such good reviews. It was very unsanitary, kitchen staff (who weren't wearing any kid of hairnet) were touching themselves, then the food. We watched the waitress handle menus, money, dirty plates, and THEN, yes, she touched the food without stopping to wash her hands even once.

We canceled our order and left the restaurant. I can home and check the health department's webpage and was not shocked to see that the restaurant received 2 out of 5 stars and has been flagged for 6 "critical" violations, which are violations that have the potential to cause foodborne illness.

I, like many other reviewers on this cite, could not believe the uncleanliness.…