The Philadelphian

11/06/09

Amazing Food, Dirty Place

by notoriousnicholas at Citysearch

Oh man is the food good. The Philadelphian is the way to go, with everything on it, don't skimp. Get yourself some French fries too. The fry sauce is really good, they put a relish in it, that adds a nice flavor.

The place is really dirty and hasn't been cleaned or remolded since the 80's. The staff aren't the friendliest bunch, but they aren't rude either. If you can get past the cover of the book, the reading (reading stands for food in this metaphor) is outrageously good, if a lot unhealthy. I would definitely recommend.

• Pros: Sandwiches, fry sauce, fresh cut fries
• Cons: Dirty, the staff isn't exactly "sociable"

10/03/09

not good

by nyfoodguy at Citysearch

this place is filthy, the sandwhiches are very dry and minus the flavor. The onion rings are pretty horid and all batter.

• Pros: good parking
• Cons: dirty

10/03/09

Probably the best Local Restaurant I've ever tasted

by ImissUtah at Citysearch

The Philadelphian is truly a local gem. I was lucky enough to be enlightened by some co-workers who had found the place. It serves great food at almost unbelievable prices. Be prepared to order when you get to the counter. You won't be sent to the back of the line, but you might hear some grumblings from the regulars behind you! :)

A 12 inch philly here is less than $6, used to be less than $5, but we moved away a couple years ago so they may have had to raise their prices. However, a 12 inch philly is more than most grown men can eat. So, you'd be fine with the shorter version. The sandwhich is built on fresh bread, then they add mayo, sliced beef, cheese, onions, mushrooms, and even jalapenos if you want them. Everything is cooked fresh to order - which explains the long wait times. If you get there after 11:30 or 12, you might wait 20-30 minutes for your food.

One thing to note is that this is a local dive - it is not exactly a place to come dressed in your Sunday best. However, my wife is a bit of a restaurant snob, and she had no problems with the decor. Once you taste their food, you won't either. Enjoy!!!

• Pros: Great Food, Generous Portions, Very Reasonable $
• Cons: Possible Long Waits during Peak Hours